Among tax-related issues, one topic that’s almost guaranteed to start an argument is that of the tax code’s role in redistributing income. Should those who have the ability to access more resources pay higher taxes than those who are less wealthy, or should those with similar incomes pay similar rates? The principles of vertical equity and horizontal equity address -- but do not resolve -- these issues.
Vertical equity is based on the principle that wealthier individuals, or those with more resource access, should pay more taxes. Also known as the “ability to pay principle of taxation,” vertical equity posits that those who can afford to pay more to support the government, should. Vertical equity is also supported by the “benefit principle of taxation,” or the idea that those who receive more benefits from government services should pay more. For example, wealthy individuals benefit more from government-supported national defense, police and fire protection, as they have more assets to lose in a war or disaster.
In contrast, the notion of horizontal equity is based on the principle that equals should be treated equally. In reference to taxes, this means that those with the same levels of income and resources should be taxed at the same rate as others within that income bracket. Many agree that horizontal equity is desirable in that it eliminates arbitrary tax variations.
Video of the Day
Brought to you by
Related pagescan i get cash from my ebt card the elastic clause definition novate definition transferring a car loan quick claim deed missouri loan repayment program army what is fannie mae homepath financing cancelling gap insurance rd easy web lease leaseback pros and cons calculating weighted average calculator manage sears credit card bank of america debit pin non cumulative dividends aarp lobbying tactics homeowners insurance foundation repair prize winnings tax va amendatory clause and real estate certification ibm stock price history how to calculate portfolio beta formula kbb black book value typical closing costs for refinance schedule a misc deductions irs 1310 form pell grant refunds sample letter for requesting donations americatab can you load a prepaid visa with a credit card refinance private student loans sallie mae universal variable life insurance pros and cons how to activate my bank of america debit card remainderman rights how to calculate debt to tangible net worth ratio salvation army furniture pick up toronto how did george pullman spend his money ad&d insurance worth it audiology technician salary what is fica oasdi tax how to contact chexsystems how much in taxes will i pay for 401k withdrawal deep discount securities permanent home swap actual powerball payout landlord won t renew lease kmart weekly circular nevada lottery scratchers how do u cash a savings bond www.chaseonlinebanking intrinsic value calculator excel ivy league scholarships georgia ebt card state tax refund md denture assistance k 1 1041 instructions ira margin state farm auto loan rates advantages and disadvantages of fixed budgeting aaa auto insurance cancellation policy how to calculate florida sales tax fafsa deceased parent how to spell prescription what is a dda withdrawal disabled veterans scholarships hud homes for sale chicago eob insurance definition sc food stamps online mortgage grace period journal entry capital lease state construction registry utah encumbering property life insurance for vets transunion fraud alerts what is the difference between capitalism and communism
Difficulties in Achieving Horizontal Equity
Though a combination of vertical and horizontal equity through the tax code is a desirable goal, obtaining a clear definition -- and thus, application -- of horizontal equity has proven to be a tough task, based on the difficulties that arise when attempting to group individuals together based on equal access to resources and wealth. Should individuals be classified in groups based on income, age or marital status? Should equal taxes refer to taxes at a certain point in an individual’s life or over an entire lifetime? These variables make horizontal equity difficult to implement in the tax code.
Tax and Income
Both horizontal and vertical equity are affected by the way income is taxed. Taxe rates can be progressive, regressive or proportional. Progressive taxes increase proportionately to income, so those who make more pay both a larger absolute amount of taxes and a greater percentage of their income. Regressive taxes decline proportionately to income, so those who make more income pay a smaller percentage in taxes than those who have less income. Regressive taxes don’t always result in a greater absolute tax payment for those with higher incomes. Proportional, or flat, taxes take the same percentage out of everyone’s income, regardless of how large or small that income is.
- Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images