Pros & Cons of Animal Shelters

by Carrie Glossmanz
Adoptions through shelters help save animals' lives.

Animal shelters play a necessary part in state and local animal control policies. They provide animals with the opportunity for a second chance at a home, and most accept both strays and animals relinquished voluntarily by their owners. Despite the benefits provided by their services, animal shelters are not without their critics. Animal rights activists cite overcrowding, euthanizing policies and staffing as reasons for concern.

Pro: Adoption Process

Animal shelters provide incentives to make adopting their animals easy for any potential new owner. While fees vary from shelter to shelter, the shelter's cost to allow adoptions is much lower than the cost of resources required to house and feed the animal. Funded by tax dollars, city and county shelters offer prices that are particularly low. Another advantage of adopting through animal shelters is the wide availability of animals. Due to the high number of animals accepted, potential owners will likely find a match that suits their preferences.

Pro: Animal Control

Local animal shelters provide a place to house stray dogs and cats that wander a neighborhood unguarded. Sheltering lowers the instance of animal attacks that would otherwise happen if all strays roamed free, while providing the animals with food and shelter. To help cut down on the number of unwanted strays, animal shelters have strict policies on spaying and neutering pets for any potential owners.

Pro: Temperament and Socialization

Most animals surrendered to animal shelters are adults. Adopting an adult animal generally comes with fewer surprises about the animal's temperament and behavior, compared with adopting a puppy or kitten. Many animal shelters provide extensive behavioral tests on animals before putting them up for adoption and generally have strict policies to inform potential owners about any destructive behavior.

Con: Administration and Staffing

Local shelters are often independently run, and their policies vary depending upon the location of the shelter, as opposed to a state or national standard. Additionally, shelters are staffed primarily by volunteers. While these workers generally have the animals' best interests in mind, the need for shelter workers outnumbers the people willing to volunteer, in some cases.

Con: Euthanizing

Every year, animal shelters euthanize approximately 3 million to 4 million dogs and cats, according to the Humane Society of the United States. The decision to euthanize the animal is left to the discretion of each individual shelter and depends upon the animal's temperament and health and the shelter's space and resources. Many shelters set a holding period in which strays are not eligible for euthanizing, giving their owners a chance to rescue them. Not all animal shelters euthanize, and those that don't distinguish themselves from the others by calling themselves no-kill animal shelters.

Con: Overcrowding

According to the Humane Society of America, 150 animal shelters operate in the United States. These shelters take in an estimated 6 million to 8 million dogs and cats every year. In some of these animal shelters, overcrowding results from taking in too many strays. Overcrowding in animal shelters leads to stressed animals, the spread of disease and animals fighting each other. The much lower adoption rates at no-kill animal shelters make overcrowding a particular problem.

Video of the Day

Brought to you by


  • "The Original Dog Bible"; Kristin Mehus-Roe; 2005

About the Author

Since 1994 Carrie Glossmanz has been writing freelance articles for publications such as "Animal Fair," "Delicious Living" and "Diabetes Health." Glossmanz is a Registered Dietitian and earned her Master of Science in nutritional sciences with an emphasis on clinical nutrition from the University of Kentucky.

Photo Credits

  • Jupiterimages/Brand X Pictures/Getty Images
Cite this Article | A tool to create a citation to reference this article Cite this Article

Related pages

which stocks have weekly optionsexcella card routing numberare student grants taxablethinkorswim tutorialsfiguring mediandivorce retirement calculatorraceway gas credit cardatm card magnetic stripwestern union expirationnevada state income taxmo ebt cardshares outstanding calculationscholarships and grants for african american malesquit deedswhat is the last 4 digits of ssncredit card reduction scamsare debt reduction programs legitimatehow to know my sbi credit card numberfuneral costs tax deductiblewheres my refund georgiasalary calculator for self employedcontribution margin equalsverizon wireless foundationhow to remove late mortgage payments from credit reportbritish petroleum stock charteffective maturityssi housing nyclottery lump sum or annual paymentshow do you calculate roaaarp medicarecompleteclaiming tax back on dental expensesrefinance with cosignerhess gas gift cardvesting deedcan i have two dental insuranceshumana gold planslender due diligenceenterprise paying with debit cardwells fargo eft routing numbercivil service retirement calculator fersletter of intent for scholarship application samplecalculate annual income from hourly wagehow to cancel green dot prepaid cardis transfer tax deductiblehow to make coin sorterhow long before a cheque goes stalebank routing number 255071981medicaid nevada qualificationskohls balance credit carddifference between grantee and grantorebt balance las vegasdiscover atm feewhat does closing escrow meanhow to minus taxes from paycheckcash advance wells fargo feenys child tax creditwsj prime interest rateadvantages and disadvantages of checking accountsucf in state tuitionhow long does it take to receive ebt cardwhat does carding meanwalmart corporate giving programconsolidate visa gift cardswhole life insurance cash value calculatorcan you transfer money from paypal to checking accountpay citgo onlineprofit sharing plan vs 401kroyal caribbean stock pricegolds gym regina cancellationcook county quit claim deed formcan non custodial parent claim child on taxeskmart check cashing